The guards at the tomb of Jesus has been either much discussed or ignored in apologetical discourse around the resurrection of Jesus. For example, here is William Lane Craig answering a question about the guards at the tomb:
Dr. Timothy McGrew, professor of philosophy at Western Michigan University, has a thorough response to the challenge of Matthew’s veracity concerning the resurrection as it pertains to the guards narrative in Matthew 27:62-66. It is well worth the read as Dr. McGrew picks apart the criticism that Torley provides against the historicity of the guards narrative. Torley claims that the narrative is unhistorical for three reasons:
- It is mentioned only in Matthew’s Gospel, not in the other three.
- This account fails to explain why the body could not have been stolen on Friday night.
- We are not told why Pilate would agree to the Jewish leaders’ request.
- The Jewish rulers would not have made such a request of Pilate, since a gentile employed by a Jew would not be allowed to work on the Sabbath.
McGrew systematically dismantles each of these reasons. A quick summary of each rebuttal:
- Rebuttal: This is an argument from silence; why can’t a single source be adequate for historicity. As McGrew points out: “Many of the events of antiquity crop up in only one source.”
- Rebuttal: This reason is assuming that the request is made on Saturday morning. Again McGrew points out: “it is not even clear from the text that the request was made on Saturday”
- Rebuttal: Just because we are not told why something happens, doesn’t mean it didn’t happen. McGrew: “this is a very odd way to object to historical evidence. Many narratives recount events without affording us an explanation for them, and sometimes we are left to guess what that explanation might be. So what?”
- Rebuttal: “Nothing in Jewish law as interpreted at the time would prevent them from making such a request.”
McGrew lays out a clear rebuttal to these charges against the guards at the tomb and will also answer other charges against the historicity of the resurrection in future posts at the blog site: What’s Wrong With the World? Definitely worth keeping up with.